'American Idol' Experts: Michael Lynche Done In By Song Selection

They'd predicted Casey James' ouster first, but our superfans weren't shocked to see Big Mike go.By Gil Kaufman Michael Lynche on "American Idol" Wednesday Photo: FOX In one of the toughest weeks to call yet, MTV News' go-to "American Idol" experts were thrown for a loop by Wednesday night's elimination. They both bet on the demise of cougar-bait cowboy Casey James, who toyed with self-parody with his ode to mother lovers, "Mrs. Robinson." But it was brawny Michael Lynche who got the b...

Read full article Share article