'American Idol' Experts Ask: Is New Top 24 The Worst Yet?

Season-nine semifinalists' rocky live debut has 'Idol' experts and fans concerned.By Gil Kaufman Tim Urban Photo: FOX The early semifinal rounds of "American Idol" are always difficult. You are bound to have some early hopefuls falling victim to first-time-on-TV jitters, a few dark horses soaring before an eventual crash and a handful of singers proving they were lucky to have gotten there in the first place. But after the first two nights of mostly panned performance, veteran "Idol"...

Read full article Share article