American Idol 9 Top 4: Who is Going Home?

Argh. Despite telling The Los Angeles Times (Check out their Buzzmeter HERE) and MTV (HERE) that I predict a Casey James boot, I’m still not totally convinced. Casey sang really well last night, overall in both his solo and duet. But the judges undermined Casey, mocking his choice of song, “Mrs. Robinson”, rather than critiquing his performance. The critiques Casey managed to get from the panel were middling to negative. Casey could get saved by folks disgusted by the judges’ treatment...

Read full article Share article