Did Matt Giraud Deserve To Be Saved On 'American Idol'?

We asked fans if the judges made the right call.By Gil Kaufman, with additional reporting by Nicole Tahan and Kathleen Newman-Bremang Matt Giraud performs on "American Idol" on Wednesday Photo: Frank Micelotta/ Getty Images For the first time, "American Idol" judges gave themselves a do-over this year: a one-shot chance to save a potential winner from being tossed from the show too early. They'd held on tightly to the save for weeks, repeatedly telling contestants they were not worthy...

Read full article Share article