Siobhan Magnus' Elimination Surprises 'American Idol' Experts

'I can only surmise that she was just too damn weird for 'American Idol,' ' MJ Santilli says.By Gil Kaufman Siobhan Magnus performs on "American Idol" Wednesday Photo: FOX On Wednesday, MTV's "American Idol" experts confidently predicted that big Michael Lynche would be facing elimination for a second time this season after a so-so outing on Shania Twain night. But a few hours later, Mike was saved (again) from the bottom and it was caterwauling, glassblowing apprentice Siobhan Magnus ...

Read full article Share article